Skip to main content
Original Issue


Once again a disqualification mars Hialeah's Flamingo after a rousing race, while Santa Anita produces a surprise Kentucky Derby contender and an unbeaten colt that may be the best 3-year-old of them all

The tiny palm-dotted community of Hialeah, on the outskirts of Miami, has moved into prominence in the past decade as a favorite growing ground of a plant of the genus Rheum known as a rhubarb. Much of Hialeah's fame rests on the classic Flamingo, a milestone race for Derby-bound 3-year-olds, and the event regularly produces rhubarb in abundance.

Exactly ten years ago Tim Tarn and Jewel's Reward provided the excitement in a race that resulted in a disputed and embarrassing disqualification. In 1962 Sunrise County won the Flamingo but was disqualified for interfering with Ridan. Somehow that made a winner out of the long shot Prego, who had about as much right to win as Jackie Gleason. Four years later came the now-famous "chicken" Flamingo, so named because Buckpasser's presence in the field terrorized Hialeah's management into permitting win betting only.

Last week, in the 39th Flamingo, rhubarb was in full bloom again, and in certain quarters—among horsemen, the press and many of the 30,902 who turned out in a cloud of pink for Hialeah's traditional closing day—the genus Rheum had a most unpleasant odor to it. The eight colts who went to the post in the mile-and-an-eighth event that is supposed to clarify the whole picture for the coming Triple Crown races gave the folks a rousing horse race all right, but when it was over, Kentucky Derby talk was almost forgotten in the heat of one more disqualification. There were harsh words between riders and officials, and a sad, depressing atmosphere of puzzlement hung over the beautiful track. More than 2,000 miles away, at equally beautiful Santa Anita, there really was Derby talk, and now that the horsemen's strike against management was over, nobody seemed particularly angry at anyone else. More important, however, there may have been some better 3-year-olds in California this week than there were at the Flamingo.

First things first, however. The Flamingo was actually won by favorite Iron Ruler in the respectable time of 1:48[1/5]. Moments later the winner's number came down, and up went that of the second-place finisher, Wise Exchange, who had trailed by a length and a quarter after running through the stretch on a convoy course.

There were no fireworks in the Flamingo until the run home. Mike Phipps's Master Bold took the early lead, as expected, with Peter Kissel's Iron Ruler a few lengths behind him. Next came Subpet, while Calumet Farm's Forward Pass, winner of the recent Everglades, put himself out of serious contention by going wide on the first turn. In the far turn Jockey Angel Cordero Jr., the hero of the Hialeah meeting with 66 winners in 39 days, drove Iron Ruler up to challenge. They took the lead away from the fast-tiring Master Bold, while Wise Exchange, the Hirsch Jacobs-trained gray son of Promised Land who races in the scarlet-and-white silks of Jacobs' partner, Isidor Bieber, was making a big move from seventh place.

Around the turn and into the stretch Master Bold quickly dropped back on the inside as Cordero drove Iron Ruler by him—and a little wide. Jockey Eddie Belmonte, meanwhile, was driving with Wise Exchange, too, and the place he wanted to drive to, obviously, was the spot vacated by Master Bold, between the rail and Iron Ruler. But Cordero had other plans, so the stewards said later. He gradually brought Iron Ruler back in toward the rail as Belmonte was going for it. Belmonte had to check Wise Exchange, change course and make a new move to the outside. When he got clear he was nearly three lengths behind Iron Ruler. After he started running again Wise Exchange flew after the leader, and he might have won it all in another 70 yards or less. As it turned out, he did win it all—$89,050 out of the gross purse of $137,000—when Belmonte claimed foul against Cordero and the stewards backed up his claim and officially reversed the order of finish.

Disqualification in a horse race is at the discretion of track stewards, but stewards, like horseplayers, do not always agree. If they had at Hialeah last week—before they threw a 20-day suspension at Cordero—they would have put up their own inquiry sign long before Belmonte had a chance to dismount and lodge his complaint. But instead of taking the initiative, Hialeah's stewards awaited Belmonte's objection—that Cordero and Iron Ruler had intimidated Wise Exchange through the stretch. Later, in explaining their own severe action (the stiffest suspensions are usually no more than 10 days), they accused Cordero of "herding" Wise Exchange by pursuing an irregular course. The films show that the stewards' decision is arguable, but, unfortunately for Cordero, the stewards are always right.

The point of it all, says Steward Keene Daingerfield, "is that even though the movies show that Wise Exchange had room to get through on the inside, nobody knew how much more herding Cordero was going to do toward the rail. Belmonte had to take back because, at the time, he didn't know if Cordero was going to come all the way in on him. If Cordero had, there would have been room for half or three-quarters of a horse to get through, but not a whole horse." Cordero's defense, in a special hearing held after the last race, wasn't convincing enough. While the stewards were plainly imputing malicious intent on his part, he insisted, in broken English, that Iron Ruler often swerves when he gets the lead but that the colt did follow a straight path once Wise Exchange drove up on the inside. His plea, of course, got nowhere, and Colonel Bieber and the Jacobs family received the Flamingo trophy to the accompaniment of a chorus of boos.

"I don't know why that should be," said Trainer Hirsch Jacobs. "It was a clear case of intimidation through not steering a proper course." Losing Trainer Eddie Yowell, probably the best sport in the house, didn't think he should have lost, but said good-naturedly, "Sure, Iron Ruler weaved in, but when I saw the other jock never stop riding, I thought they'd let our number stay up. It's one of those things that happen in this game, and you have to accept it."

Are any in this field Kentucky Derby horses? Well, the picture has changed a lot now, says Jacobs, who hardly considered nominating Wise Exchange for the May 4th classic until a few weeks ago. "I thought Vitriolic was far the best," Jacobs explains, "but if he's out for a while, I suppose that gives any number of us a chance, at least for the time being. This colt of mine isn't anywhere near as good as Reflected Glory, who won the Flamingo a year ago, but he is very fast, runs honest and should really like a distance. We'll run him in the Florida Derby, then take him to New York and we might get to Churchill Downs yet." Indeed he might—if this gray, who has now won only three of 25 starts, can keep his sore shins well enough through the Jacobs training routine, which isn't so much training as just plain racing whenever possible.

Unlucky Iron Ruler is also headed for the March 30th Florida Derby, in which he and Wise Exchange have an outside chance to run against Vitriolic, Ogden Phipps's 1967 2-year-old champion. Ailing following the Everglades, in which he was cut twice, Vitriolic may skip the rest of the Florida campaign if he doesn't come back 100% in the next two weeks.

Iron Ruler aside, those beaten in the Flamingo had no cause for complaint. Forward Pass has always been something of an in-and-outer, even though he keeps getting part of the purse. Master Bold, front-runner that he is, will have to change tactics if he hopes to get a distance, and Subpet just doesn't appear to have the class. The same applies, at least now, to Verbatim, Salerno and San Roque. And there is nothing much else in Florida, unless you want to consider Warner Jones's Go Marching, whom Trainer Horatio Luro has in his barn. "Let's just say that he is progressing slowly," says Luro. "But slowly doesn't mean wonderfully; it means hopefully."

There were Derby hopes in California, too, last week, most of them evinced by Owners William Haggin Perry and Hastings Harcourt. Perry, the sometime partner of Claiborne Farm's Owner Arthur B. (Bull) Hancock, is a familiar name in racing these days, mostly because of the success of his mares, Gamely and Princessnesian. If two of his Triple Crown prospects, Jacinto and Boldnesian, had not done themselves in before the major eastern classics in recent years, he would be even better known. They know him extremely well in California right now because he is the leading owner at Santa Anita and because he may have the best 3-year-old in the country. It is too early to tell for sure, but Perry, a Middleburg, Va. refugee from the horse-show world, and his astute trainer, Jim Maloney, are counting on a colt named Dewan. By Bold Ruler out of the brilliant race mare Sunshine Nell, by Sun Again, Dewan has never run in a stakes race and won't until the March 16th San Felipe. But he is unbeaten in four starts. His fourth victory, at a mile and a 16th last week, was impressive enough, but what adds to his distinction is his extreme willingness to run.

In recent weeks, despite Perry's California successes with a marvelously diversified stable, the West Coast racing news has largely centered around a man whose name seems more suitable to an English character actor. Hastings Harcourt is a large, ruddy-faced gent of 60 who turned over the family publishing firm of Harcourt, Brace & World to hired management in order to move to California in pursuit of horse racing glory. But, unlike a lot of California racing figures who talk big about money, Harcourt has been dipping into his tweeds for the genuine article. He has spent more than $5 million in three years, has a $2 million ranch, Flag Is Up Farms, about 120 miles from Los Angeles in the Santa Ynez Valley, and now owns 50 horses, including the stallion Fleet Discovery and an Argentine full brother to Forli. A few days ago he paid $1,050,000 to Mrs. Henry Carnegie Phipps and her grandson Dinny for the Bold Ruler stallion Successor, champion 2-year-old of 1966. Why did he do it? "I'm buying everything worthwhile," says Harcourt, "and here was a chance to go all the way overnight. We may have opened the door for Californians to buy better stallions, instead of just talking about it."

Last week Harcourt, who employs Hollywood Press Agent Helen Morgan to let the world know what he is doing, wasn't just talking about racing; he was enjoying some success with it. As he and his wife Fran, Farm Manager Marvin (Monty) Roberts and Trainer Farrell W. Jones looked on, their $5,000 Del Mar purchase, Sharivari, won the one-mile San Jacinto Stakes at Santa Anita, beating Bill Perry's Dignitas, Charles Engelhard's Alley Fighter and the proven stakes winner Don B. Sharivari may not be able to stand the strain of many hard races like this one, but he is one of the better West Coast colts in this odd season. And he could improve. He is by What's Ahead, who was in the last crop of the great Nearco.

Whatever happens to Sharivari won't come as much of a surprise to Hastings and Fran Harcourt. "I'm known in the game as a new pigeon," said the winning owner last week. "But I really don't mind, because I thought it would be fun to try this sport, and it has been fun. If Sharivari can do us some good in the Santa Anita Derby and stays sound, we'll go all the way—to Kentucky, that is."

It is this sort of refreshing optimism, sprinkled over the rhubarb, that keeps racing enthusiasts chanting, "I've got the horse right here...."


Turning into the stretch, Angel Cordero on Iron Ruler glances back at Eddie Belmonte and Wise Exchange (No. 8) just before the incident that caused the foul claim (right).


Long shot Sharivari leads Alley Fighter to the wire, bringing a handsome mutuel payoff and a wide smile to the face of Owner Harcourt as he congratulates his rider after the race.