- Publish date:
Letters
Thanks for the cover story on the Giants' amazing World Series win. When Brian Wilson blew strike three past Nelson Cruz, tears of joy rolled down my cheeks. I thought about my dad being a 13-year-old kid when the Giants first came to San Francisco and about the decades of futility and agonizing near-misses since then. A great big hole in the collective souls of Giants fans everywhere has just closed up.
David Picconi, Toms River, N.J.
Tom Verducci wrote a wonderful article on the Giants' young pitchers (Giant Moment, Nov. 8), but I was disappointed that he failed to mention the tremendous job that rookie catcher Buster Posey did handling them. Posey's performance was remarkable considering he didn't join the team until the end of May and didn't become a starter until Bengie Molina was traded to the Rangers in June.
Van Moeller, Rodeo, Calif.
Am I the only one thrilled with the Giants' victory simply because Barry Bonds wasn't part of the team? No performance-enhancing drugs, only rally thongs, gleeful castoffs and dyed beards. Our national pastime is regenerating its roots.
Thomas Meachum
Palm Harbor, Fla.
Your story about the World Series references the 1956 Yankees as the last team to have so many "homegrown starters in a World Series that young." The author includes Bob Turley and Dan—which should be Don—Larsen in his list. Actually, both Turley and Larsen were members of the 1954 Orioles before joining the Yankees. Although they were not homegrown, they were still examples of superb scouting talent.
Mike Strong, York, Pa.
Common Interests
I enjoyed Austin Murphy's article on coach Kyle Whittingham and the Utah football program (The Right Call, Nov. 8). However, Murphy's suggestion that the similarity between the Utes and BYU (merely their shared Mormonism) should mitigate their rivalry is naive. Rivals aren't rivals because they're different; rivals are rivals because they're the same. Does Murphy also think that the shared values of the American military should lessen the famed Army-Navy football rivalry because the schools have a "common cause"?
Paul W. Brennan, New York City
My first thought after hearing Utah would be leaving the Mountain West to join the Pac-10 was concern about what will happen to its rivalry with BYU. Hopefully it will remain intact for years to come.
Brynn Park
American Fork, Utah
Passing Grades
The great quarterbacks mentioned in Tim Layden's fine piece (The Art of the Pass, Nov. 8) owe a debt of thanks to football's first great passer, Hall of Famer Benny Friedman. Friedman revolutionized the game in the 1920s and '30s with his unprecedented accuracy. As Knute Rockne said of Friedman's talent, "He's so good he could hit a dime at 40 yards."
Murray Greenberg
Hewlett Harbor, N.Y.
Your article on what separates a "good quarterback" from an "alltime master" was an excellent counterpoint to the author's previous story on the running game (Crash Course, Aug. 23). As with all great artists, the masters of the passing game bring something to their craft that goes beyond physical skills. Layden calls it an "elusive ultimate measure" of the passer. Others might call it "genius."
Jim Wilken, Marion, N.C.
Eternal Flame
Bulls center Joakim Noah (The Fire Inside, Nov. 8) epitomizes what Generation X is all about. He doesn't play by the rules and he keeps on fighting until he succeeds, regardless of situation. Throw in that snarky tongue of his and you've really got something special.
Tyler Workman
Provo, Utah
If the majority of players in the NBA played with Noah's intensity there would not be so many empty seats in the arenas at regular season games.
Lee Koppelman
Hackensack, N.J.
Taking a Stand
After reading Selena Roberts's story on the controversy at Silsbee High (POINT AFTER, Nov. 8), I really believe that the rest of the cheerleading squad should have supported H.S. in her protest against her alleged attacker. It would have made quite a statement if Rakheem Bolton heard nothing but silence each time he went to the foul line. While the actions of the school's administration aren't surprising to me, the lack of support by the other cheerleaders is. A missed opportunity to support one of their own.
Bruce Kaplan
Southampton, N.J.
If the school had allowed H.S. to protest during the game, it would have been unfair to the basketball players and the other cheerleaders who were also participating. Parents and fans would wonder why she wasn't cheering for that one particular player, and the focus would have shifted from the game to the controversy.
Samuel Miller, Seattle
Contact SI
LETTERS
E-mail SI at letters@SI.timeinc.com or fax SI at 212-467-2417. Letters should include the writer's full name, address and home telephone number and may be edited for clarity and space.
CUSTOMER SERVICE AND SUBSCRIPTIONS
For 24/7 service, go to SI.com/customerservice. Call 1-800-528-5000 or write to SI at P.O. Box 30602, Tampa, FL 33630-0602. To purchase reprints of SI covers, go to SIcovers.com.
ADVERTISING
For ad rates, an editorial calendar or a media kit, e-mail SI at SIpubqueries@timeinc.com.
For reprints of SI covers visit SIcovers.com
PHOTO
AL TIELEMANS (COVER)
PHOTO
