Skip to main content
Original Issue



This may strike some as being odd because I was in charge of Michael Vick's prosecution in 2007, but I too am rooting for him. I have seen hundreds of men and women go to prison. Many, the greedy and the reckless alike, serve their time and come out again with a second chance at life, as is their right. Vick has a better shot than most, and I honestly hope he makes it.

Chuck Rosenberg, Washington, D.C.

For reprints of SI covers, visit

The Ravens' Donte' Stallworth served 24 days in jail and was suspended by the NFL for the entire 2009 season after he killed a pedestrian while driving under the influence. He is now back in uniform, and no one blinks an eye. Vick (Is It O.K. to Cheer? Nov. 29) served 19 months in prison for his involvement in a dogfighting enterprise. All things considered, I think he has paid his debt to society.

Jack Ross, Holden, Mass.

I ripped off the cover of Vick as soon as I received the magazine in the mail. Yes, Vick served his time in prison and as a free man has every right to play and earn his millions, but that does not mean he is any less of a monster. Football success aside, he still remains a big bad wolf disguised not as a sheep but as an Eagle.

Erik Ormberg

Bellingham, Mass.

After reading the article about Vick, I realized that he only spoke about what he had lost during his punishment. He never once showed empathy for the animals he harmed and killed. He came across as someone focused on himself with no evidence of a conscience.

Stan Crandall, Falconer, N.Y.


With tears in my eyes, I sit here hoping that Michael Vick reads your heart-wrenching article about Jill Costello's battle with cancer (The Courage of Jill Costello, Nov. 29) and fully realizes what having a second chance means. He should also note the loving role of Jack, Jill's Maltese puppy, who was an inspiration to her in her final days.

Jim McCormick

Lake St. Louis, Mo.

What a moving story by Chris Ballard on the dedication of a young woman to her sport and her school. Costello's courage is a testament to the human spirit, and her story is a poignant reminder of the true meaning of life and sport.

Howard Haddock

Rockwall, Texas

There's an adage that says, Life is not measured by the number of breaths you take but by the moments that take your breath away. Reading your heroic, gallant story on this brave young woman was such a moment for me.

Mark N. Levine

Chubbuck, Idaho

Not So Fast

SI got a bit carried away with its declaration on the cover that, JIMMIE JOHNSON IS THE GREATEST DRIVER EVER, YES (The Fifth Cup Is the Sweetest, Nov. 29). As good as he unquestionably is, Johnson is competing in the minor leagues of auto racing. The most technically advanced vehicles in sports race on the Formula One circuit.

Bob Sherwood

Pound Ridge, N.Y.

A year ago I wrote a letter to SI, furious that Johnson was labeled the "greatest ever" in a story about his fourth consecutive championship. However, after watching his magnificent racing in the Chase this year, I must say that I regret those words. Seeing a champion crowned for the fifth straight time doesn't happen every day.

Conner J. Viets

Overland Park, Kans.

A Little Too Late

Thank you for giving President Bill Clinton a forum in which he was able to explain the U.S.'s case for hosting the 2022 FIFA World Cup (SCORECARD, Nov. 29). I enjoyed his essay and was hoping the U.S. would get the bid and bring the Cup back stateside. I am confused, however, as to why you chose to publish this article only a week before the announcement. Maybe if it had run a year ago, more people would have been behind the effort and would have rallied for the cause.

Mark Rhudy


Giant Relief

Cody Ross (POINT AFTER, Nov. 29) represents everything good about baseball and professional sports. To see him beat my Phillies in the NL Championship Series single-handedly didn't make me happy, but his enthusiasm for the game far outshined my disappointment. If Barry Bonds had Ross's attitude, maybe the Giants would have won the World Series a long time ago.

Joe Dugan

Boca Raton, Fla.

Contact SI


E-mail SI at or fax SI at 212-467-2417. Letters should include the writer's full name, address and home telephone number and may be edited for clarity and space.


For 24/7 service, go to Call 1-800-528-5000 or write to SI at P.O. Box 30602, Tampa, FL 33630-0602. To purchase reprints of SI covers, go to


For ad rates, an editorial calendar or a media kit, e-mail SI at

If You Do Not Want the Swimsuit Issue

The annual SI Swimsuit Issue will be published in February. If you're a subscriber and would prefer not to receive it, call our customer service center toll free at 1-800-528-5000 and let us know. If you choose not to receive the SI Swimsuit Issue, SI will extend your subscription.